‘We are extremely reserved right up until we walk up to the ballot box’

On the heels of Al Franken’s Minnesota State Supreme Court victory, David Carr has a great piece in the Times attempting to explain how Franken’s just-odd-enough persona fits well into the realm of Minnesota politics.

Yes, Minnesotans vote like crazy. At 77.8 percent, the state had the highest turnout in last year’s very busy presidential election. But yes, sometimes Minnesotans’ votes seem just plain crazy as well.

Other states, other voters, express alienation by staying home on Election Day. But Minnesotans take a more civic approach to their estrangement, showing up at the polls and replacing the bums with some choices that scan as odd from a distance. (We might mention that the Minnesota state bird is actually a loon, but there is other less avian evidence of Minnesotans’ idiosyncrasy.)

In Minnesota, there is a kind of populist approach that is less progressive than a reflex, a notion that politics belongs to citizens, and politicians only rent their positions.

The rest here.

If we’re as politically engaged as we seem to be, won’t the potential loss of a seat in Congress be devastating? I’m not excited about the prospect of less representation, but watching the cross-district battles that would ensue if we turned it down to seven would be a blast.

2 Responses

  1. What’s the definition of a Lutheran? Someone who pretends not to recognize you in the liguor store.

    Minnesotans are passive-aggressive. They’ll install a Franken or Ventura just to get back at the system.

  2. I worked in politics for about 10 years and cannot pretend to understand Minnesota’s political temperament. You explain to me a state that on three successive statewide elections chose Paul Wellstone, Rod Grams and Jesse Ventura to be their officeholders. Explain to me the commonplace scenario – in Minnesota at least – of a party rejecting its own incumbent officials in order to endorse in-party extremist challengers. A state that – as Mr. Carr points out – turns out to vote but as often as not does so to choose people with no qualifications for the offices they seek.

    Interesting system we got here.

    - Austin

Leave a Reply